Methodology · 2026

How we calculate the cost of a hire

HiringMath is a neutral, employer-side tool. We do not sell payroll software, take a commission on hires, or favor W-2 over 1099. Every figure is computed by one pure, unit-tested engine from public, citable sources — the same engine that powers the live calculator and all 51 state pages. Here is exactly how it works and where the numbers come from.

Data sources

We use primary, government-published sources for every tax constant. Benefit defaults are drawn from the most recent national employer survey and are clearly labeled as editable assumptions, not fixed taxes.

SourceWhat we use it for
IRS Publication 15 (Circular E)
Federal employer FICA rates and wage bases, FUTA rate and wage base
U.S. Department of Labor — FLSA & state UI program data
Unemployment-insurance framework and federal FUTA offset
51 state unemployment agencies (50 states + DC)
New-employer SUI/SUTA rates and taxable wage bases per jurisdiction
State labor & revenue departments
Extra employer payroll programs (paid family leave, SDI, job-training taxes) and state income-tax treatment
KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey
Default health-insurance premium assumptions for the worked examples

How the engine works

The fully-loaded W-2 cost is the sum of five layers on top of base salary. Each is computed from the inputs you provide and your state's actual rates:

  1. Federal FICA 6.2% Social Security on the first $176,100 of wages, plus 1.45% Medicare on all wages.
  2. FUTA 0.6% net federal unemployment tax on the first $7,000 of wages.
  3. State SUI / SUTA— your state's new-employer rate applied to its taxable wage base (the national average new-employer rate is 2.07%). We default to the new-employer rate — what a business actually pays before it has a claims history.
  4. Workers' compensation — a premium per $100 of payroll, defaulted from typical office-role rates and fully editable.
  5. Benefits & overhead — health insurance, a retirement match, other benefits, and overhead (equipment, software, space), each an editable assumption shown transparently in the breakdown.

The 1099 side is simpler: the contract amount plus an optional admin percentage, with no employer payroll taxes or benefits. We then solve for the breakeven contract rate — the 1099 rate at which a contractor costs exactly what the W-2 hire does — so the comparison is honest in both directions.

Assumptions & update cadence

Tax constants are current for the 2026 tax year and were last reviewed on 2026-06-01. We update federal constants when the IRS publishes new figures and refresh state SUI rates and wage bases as each agency posts them, typically at year-end. Benefit and overhead defaults are starting points — change them to match your business, and the answer recomputes locally and instantly.

Limitations

HiringMath produces planning estimates, not tax, legal, or accounting advice. Experience-rated SUI rates, local taxes, industry-specific workers'-comp classifications, and individual benefit plans will move your real number. For filing and classification decisions, confirm with a licensed CPA or employment attorney. Explore the full state payroll-tax reference or open any state page to see the exact rates we apply.